18 Nov 2026, Wed

A Chula Vista Seller Wants $35,000 for a Fiero Pretending to Be an F40, and Ferrari Has Won This Fight Before

Get The Auto Wire in your inbox
Driving news, policy watch and the auto industry’s biggest moves. Free, no spam.

A seller in Chula Vista, California, is asking $35,000 for a Ferrari F40 kit car built around a Pontiac Fiero, according to a Facebook Marketplace listing that showed the car in stock on Nov. 16.

Two lines of listing copy

The listing text is two lines long. It gives the condition as “Used – like new” and describes the car as “base off Fiero v6,” with an automatic transmission. It lists no VIN, mileage, title status, horsepower figure, or builder, so none of those is confirmed.

Ferrari says it built 1,311 F40s between 1987 and 1992, each with a 2,936cc twin-turbocharged V8 that the company lists at 478 bhp. The Chula Vista car starts from a Fiero V6 instead, which leaves the F40 shape as the main thing the name refers to.

The 1991 case: Ferrari v. Roberts

On Sept. 5, 1991, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit upheld an injunction that kept Carl Roberts, doing business as Roberts Motor Company, from making or selling two Ferrari look-alikes. His Miami Spyder copied the Daytona Spyder and his Miami Coupe copied the Testarossa. He sold fiberglass body shells that buyers usually bolted onto a donor car, and the opinion names a Chevrolet Corvette and a Pontiac Fiero as examples. The case is Ferrari S.p.A. Esercizio Fabbriche Automobili e Corse v. Roberts, No. 90-5734, reported at 944 F.2d 1235. A federal district court in eastern Tennessee had issued the injunction first.

The appeals court held that the exterior shape of a car can be protected as trade dress under section 43(a) of the Lanham Act without a design patent, as long as the shape has come to identify its maker in buyers’ minds, which lawyers call secondary meaning. Ferrari held no design patent on either car. The court relied on Roberts’s admitted intentional copying, survey evidence, and witness testimony. It also held that confusion does not have to happen at the point of sale, because the law protects a maker’s reputation as well as the person buying. Circuit Judge Kennedy dissented in part, arguing that clear labeling would cure any confusion and that the injunction was too broad.

Where the ruling stops

The F40 does not appear in the opinion, and the Fiero appears only as a donor car, so the Sixth Circuit never ruled on this body shape. Roberts was a business selling bodies, and the injunction covered making and selling his two models. The opinion does not address an individual reselling one finished car, and I found no filing or statement from Ferrari about the Chula Vista listing. The Sixth Circuit covers Kentucky, Michigan, Ohio, and Tennessee. Chula Vista is in the Ninth Circuit, where the 1991 opinion is persuasive but not binding.

The federal replica program runs through the rights holder

Congress later wrote the same premise into a federal safety exemption. The 2015 FAST Act directed NHTSA to exempt up to 325 replica vehicles a year from federal safety standards for low-volume manufacturers, now in 49 U.S.C. § 30114(b). The replica must resemble a vehicle built at least 25 years earlier, which an F40 from the early 1990s clears. It must also be built under a license for the “product configuration, trade dress, trademark, or patent” of the original, granted by the original manufacturer, its successors, or whoever holds those rights now. NHTSA’s rule published March 9, 2022 set up the registration program in 49 CFR part 586 and requires a replica’s VIN to code the original’s make, model, and model year. For an F40, that route runs through Ferrari. The listing does not say the Chula Vista car was built under it.

What California asks for before a kit car gets plates

A car outside that program is a homebuilt or kit car as far as California is concerned. The DMV calls these specially constructed vehicles: homemade or kit cars built for private use rather than by a licensed manufacturer. To register one, an authorized DMV employee has to verify the car at a DMV office. The owner submits a Statement of Construction (form REG 5036), bills of sale or receipts for the engine, frame, transmission, and body, and an electronic Vehicle Safety Systems Inspection certificate, and the car needs a smog certification.

Every piece of that paperwork follows a part. The listing doesn’t say whether this car has any of it, or who’s holding the receipts. Without it, nobody can say whether the next owner gets plates in California.

Should a one-off copy of a long-discontinued Ferrari be treated as a harmless hobby project, or should the rights holder get the final say over who builds and sells it?

By Johnny Lloyd

Johnny covers what happens to cars and drivers after the sale: theft rings, speed and plate-reader cameras, dealer fees and title fights, data breaches and app tracking, and the lawsuits and police records behind crashes, takeovers, and fires. He reports on what the records show, not what the press release says.

Join the conversation

No comments yet — be the first to share your take.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *