A New York woman is among a growing number of rental car customers who have been subjected to high-risk traffic stops after their vehicles were mistakenly flagged as stolen in law enforcement databases.
A Frightening Traffic Stop
The woman had rented a vehicle from an Avis location on Manhattan’s Upper West Side in June and was later driving through Ohio when sheriff’s deputies surrounded her car. Bodycam footage obtained by NBC’s I-Team shows officers ordering her to turn off the engine and exit the vehicle with weapons drawn, after the rental had been incorrectly listed as stolen.
2014 Dodge Viper TA Sells for $176,000 in Online Auction
No Charges, But Lasting Impact
“I’m so scared,” the woman said after deputies determined the stop was a mistake. She was not charged, but described the experience as deeply unsettling. “A whole process needs to change so they do not have police pulling people over for no reason,” she told NBC.
A Records Error
Records show the vehicle had actually been removed from the stolen vehicle database months before the traffic stop occurred. Investigators believe a breakdown in communication between agencies left the vehicle’s plate incorrectly flagged in the system. Avis has not issued a public response regarding the incident.
Part of a Larger Pattern
Attorneys say this case is not an isolated incident. Daniel Whitney Jr., a Maryland-based attorney who has represented at least ten clients in similar situations, attributes the problem to inconsistent tracking systems and theft reports filed without adequate verification. “I get the sense that the priority is more so processing things quickly than processing them carefully,” Whitney said.
A History of Similar Incidents
Hertz previously paid $168 million in 2022 to settle claims involving more than 300 customers who were wrongly accused of vehicle theft. With additional cases continuing to surface, consumer advocates are calling for rental companies and law enforcement agencies to improve coordination and verification processes to prevent similar incidents in the future.