A wrecker service recovered a 2005 Jaguar from the Big Black River in Carroll County, Miss., after receding water exposed it over the weekend, and Sheriff Clint Walker said the VIN shows the car was stolen out of Holmes County in 2010. WJTV’s report names no suspect and no charge. So the Jaguar joins a familiar pile: stolen-car recoveries that outnumber arrests.
How a 2010 theft showed up in a river
Walker said the receding water uncovered the car. Someone filmed it and posted the video to social media, and when deputies saw the footage, he said, they knew it needed to be investigated. Deputies went to the location, found the Jaguar in the mud and had a wrecker service bring it out. No one was inside the car, Walker said.
He said the VIN tied the car to a Hinds County owner and to a 2010 theft out of Holmes County. Sixteen years in river mud, and the VIN still talked. The same kind of check flagged a stolen Mazda offered to a Eugene dealer this month.

“You never can tell what lies beneath murky water,” Walker said in the statement WJTV carried. He asked residents to contact the Sheriff’s Office immediately when they see something unusual, even if they still plan to post it online, and said he was glad this was an empty car and not the result of a crash. The sheriff’s account does not say how the Jaguar ended up in the river.
Why the river gave it up now
A federal drought status update dated Nov. 12, built on U.S. Drought Monitor data valid Nov. 10, put 92% of Mississippi in moderate to exceptional drought. It said August through October was the warmest such period on record for the state and the fifth driest, and that parts of Deer Creek in Mississippi had dried up.
Whether 16 years protects whoever took it
Mississippi’s default clock for a crime not named in Section 99-1-5 is two years. The section’s list of offenses that can be prosecuted at any time includes larceny. Car theft is not named on that list, but Section 97-17-42, in the version that covered a 2010 theft, called taking a motor vehicle larceny and set the punishment by the vehicle’s value. Read together, those two sections point toward no time limit for a 2010 car theft.
I found no appellate ruling that says so. The one Court of Appeals of Mississippi decision I found that touched the two-year clock for car theft, Dearman v. State in 2017, turned on a guilty plea, which the court said waives a limitations defense, and on a petition filed years late. A prosecutor would have to make the argument first, and WJTV’s report does not say anyone has been identified.
The statute reads differently now. Under Senate Bill 2174, effective July 1, 2024, motor vehicle theft is written as a felony punishable by a fine of up to $10,000, up to 15 years in the Department of Corrections, or both, per the bill as sent to the governor. A second offense carries up to $20,000 and five to 20 years. A 2010 theft would be judged under the law as it stood then, not under those penalties.
What is still unanswered
WJTV’s report does not say which Jaguar model it is, whether the Hinds County owner has been told, or whether deputies have a lead on who took it. Those are questions for the Carroll County Sheriff’s Office.
Should a 2010 car theft still be prosecutable in 2026 if deputies identify who took it, or does 16 years run out the clock on that kind of crime?

