James D. Hubbard was already out on bond in an odometer-rollback case in Elwood, Kansas, when Elwood police arrested him a second time. In a Nov. 16 update, Police Chief Brandon Whetstine said investigators had developed probable cause to tie Hubbard to an alleged operation that dismantled stolen vehicles and tampered with vehicle identification numbers, according to the department’s statement as reported by KNZA and KQTV. Hubbard is being held in the Doniphan County Jail on a $300,000 bond.
The department has sent 23 more recommended charges, 20 felonies and three misdemeanors, to the Doniphan County Attorney’s Office, which decides whether to file them. Police said the list includes drug counts from a search of Hubbard’s property, alleging possession of methamphetamine, THC and drug paraphernalia. None of the allegations has been proven in court, and police have not said how many vehicles or buyers are involved.
From a search warrant at J&M Auto to six felony counts
The case started Oct. 29, when Elwood officers served a search warrant at J&M Auto, a used-car dealer in the small Doniphan County town across the Missouri River from St. Joseph, Missouri. The department said in a release, as reported by KQTV, that its investigation had established probable cause that Hubbard and the dealership rolled back odometers to misrepresent mileage and falsified information on official documents. He was arrested on allegations including theft by deception, odometer tampering, providing false information and perjury.
KNZA reported that Doniphan County District Court records show six felony counts: two of theft, two of unlawful acts concerning odometers, one of perjury and one of making false information. Police have not said which document the perjury count rests on. Wathena police helped serve the warrant, and the Kansas Highway Patrol’s Motor Vehicle Theft Unit and the Kansas Department of Revenue’s fraud investigators also assisted. The revenue department titles vehicles and licenses dealers, and K.S.A. 74-2135 lets the patrol set the procedures for VIN checks and for tests that detect odometer tampering.
Kansas puts a rolled-back odometer near the bottom of its felony scale
Under K.S.A. 21-5835, it is a crime to knowingly set back an odometer so it shows fewer miles than the car has traveled, or to sell a car with intent to defraud while knowing its odometer was set back. Either one is a severity level 9 nonperson felony. Kansas ranks felonies from level 1, the most serious, to level 10. The VIN law, K.S.A. 8-116, makes altering a VIN, or selling a vehicle whose original VIN was altered, a level 10 felony, and knowingly possessing such a vehicle a class C misdemeanor. Those VIN subsections are written for vehicles with no stolen parts. Police have not released which statutes the 23 recommended counts cite.
For anyone who bought a car from the lot, the civil statutes carry more weight than the criminal ones. K.S.A. 50-651 makes a person who violates the Kansas odometer law liable to the aggrieved consumer for a civil penalty of up to $10,000 per violation, set by the court, on top of any federal remedy. The federal remedy, 49 U.S.C. 32710, is three times the buyer’s actual damages or $10,000, whichever is greater, when the violation was committed with intent to defraud, and the court must award attorney’s fees to a buyer who wins. On a cheap used car, actual damages can be small. The $10,000 floor and the fee clause are what make those cases worth bringing. The federal clock runs two years from when the claim accrues.
The stolen-car allegations put the cars themselves at risk

The first arrest was about mileage, which a buyer can usually fix with money. The second is about whether a buyer gets to keep the car. Subsection (d) of K.S.A. 8-116 says every law enforcement officer in Kansas who knows of a vehicle whose VIN has been destroyed, removed, altered or defaced shall seize it, and subsection (e) declares that vehicle contraband, to be handled under the state’s seized-property law. Nothing in the seizure subsection turns on what the current owner knew. A buyer holding a clean-looking Kansas title can still lose the vehicle, and if it turns out to be stolen, the theft victim or its insurer has the stronger claim. Paperwork is no protection on its own: in a Cleveland washed-title case The Auto Wire covered, a buyer holding a clean-looking title still lost the car to a lienholder.
What a buyer can fall back on is the dealer’s bond. K.S.A. 8-2404 requires every Kansas used- or new-vehicle dealer to carry a $50,000 corporate surety bond for the benefit of any aggrieved retail or wholesale buyer or seller. The same subsection caps the surety’s total liability for all claims at the amount of the bond. That is $50,000 for every customer combined, not per car, and the surety can cancel with 30 days’ notice to the state, after which it is not on the hook for later violations. Police have not said whether J&M Auto’s dealer license or bond is still in force. If the alleged scheme reached many cars, buyers would be dividing one $50,000 pool.
Kansas has prosecuted dealer rollbacks before
In March 2024, a federal grand jury in Wichita indicted Adam Newbrey of Derby, who the U.S. Attorney’s Office said operated three Wichita used-car dealerships, on 27 counts, including nine of odometer tampering. Prosecutors alleged he bought used vehicles in Kansas and Oklahoma, altered the odometers and used fraudulent documents to get Kansas titles showing the false mileage. The Kansas Department of Revenue’s investigators worked that case with NHTSA’s Office of Odometer Fraud Investigation. The release noted that an indictment is only an allegation.
Nationally, NHTSA estimates that more than 450,000 vehicles are sold each year with false odometer readings. The Elwood allegations pair mileage fraud with a dismantling operation, the kind of setup alleged in an Indianapolis case where 16 stolen cars were reportedly found mid-teardown. VIN tampering is what links the two: a stolen car or its parts can be sold under another vehicle’s identity and title, which is why a buyer checking only the paperwork can miss it.
What Elwood police want from J&M Auto buyers
The department has asked anyone who bought a vehicle from J&M Auto with inaccurate or misrepresented mileage, or who has information about the case, to call the Elwood Police Department at 913-365-0021.
For anyone shopping a small lot, NHTSA’s checklist starts with comparing the mileage on the title to the odometer and to service records and oil-change stickers, then looking at tire wear and the wear on the pedals, and running a vehicle history report on the VIN. Matching the VIN on the dashboard plate to the label on the driver’s door jamb and to the title takes a minute, and under K.S.A. 8-116 a mismatch is reason enough for police to take the car. One gap: according to NHTSA, model year 2010 and older vehicles are exempt from the federal written mileage disclosure, so on an older car the title may not carry a sworn odometer reading at all.
The Doniphan County Attorney decides next
Whether the 23 recommended counts become charges is up to the Doniphan County Attorney’s Office. No filing on the new counts had been reported as of the department’s Nov. 16 update, and no court date for either arrest has been made public. The local reports did not identify an attorney for Hubbard, and no statement from him or a lawyer on his behalf has been made public. He remains in custody on the $300,000 bond, and the six counts from October are pending in Doniphan County District Court.
Fifty thousand dollars, split among every customer one dealer ever burned. Should Kansas raise the bond, or do federal triple damages and attorney’s fees already give buyers a big enough stick?

